Bug My observations

[Fillip H.]

I can't find any og:url meta tag in forumdisplay, other than that I've taken care of the showthread URL

I'll move on to fixing the URLs with numbers at the end

 

[janslu]

It's getting better and better really fast! Thank you for your work! I'm so happy there's gonna be a supported replacement for vbseo zombie

I just had a little time to test new b5 release. I've been comparing output of few different pages and I have only found a few rather minor things.

forum homepage:

slight difference in og:url:

dbseo:
<meta property="og:url" content="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum" />
vbseo:
<meta property="og:url" content="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/" />

Proper one (one less redirect) is from vbseo.

in footer:

vbseo:
<form action="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/" method="get" id="footer_select" class="footer_select">
dbseo:
<form action="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/index.php" method="get" id="footer_select" class="footer_select">

Specific forum display:

1. meta:

vbseo adds words from forum title to description and keywords:
<meta name="keywords" content="Ciąż,poród,połóg,Ciąża, poród, połóg, ciąża, poród, dzieci, dziecko, niemowlę, niemowlęta, rozwój, karmienie, mama, tata, wychowanie" />
<meta name="description" content="Ciąża, poród, połóg - Wszystko o ciąży, porodzie i połogu." />
dbseo:
<meta name="keywords" content="Ciąża, poród, połóg, ciąża, poród, dzieci, dziecko, niemowlę, niemowlęta, rozwój, karmienie, mama, tata, wychowanie" />
<meta name="description" content="Wszystko o ciąży, porodzie i połogu." />

I don't think vbseo's way is a good idea as I have a lot of duplicates...

2 og:

vbseo:
<meta property="og:description" content="Ciąża, poród, połóg - Wszystko o ciąży, porodzie i połogu." />
<meta property="og:url" content="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/ciaza-porod-polog-f14/" />
dbseo:
<meta property="og:description" content="Forum dla przyszłych i obecnych rodziców. Tematy: poróda, ciąża, przebieg ciąży, dzieci, niemowlęta, wychowanie, rodzina." />
<meta property="og:url" content="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum" />

And here vbseo works better - the values are specific for each forum.

3. lastpost:

vbseo:
<a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/ciaza-porod-polog-f14/zasniad-groniasty-63427/#post9950520" class="lastpostdate understate" title="Go to last post"><img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/images/buttons/lastpost-right.png" alt="Go to last post" /></a>
dbseo:
<a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/ciaza-porod-polog-f14/zasniad-groniasty-63427-post9950520/#post9950520" class="lastpostdate understate" title="Go to last post"><img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/images/buttons/lastpost-right.png" alt="Go to last post" /></a>

My personal opinion is that vbseo's way is better. It gives a clear, defined url for each thread, with post data added as an anchor at the end. Dbseo links to a different url. But we've touched the issue before ;-)


SOCIAL GROUPS:
Remember the need for -a after digits in title? It seems it wasn't needed in social groups in vbseo :-|

vbseo: <a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/groups/805-lutowki-2013.html">
dbseo: <a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/groups/805-lutowki-2013-a.html">

ALBUMS:
Different values for thumbnail alt. Is this something you worked on? It's not really important for me, just noticed when browsing diffs:

dbseo: <img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=398830&thumb=1" border="0" alt="-image.jpg" width="180" height="134" />
vbseo: <img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=398830&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Enter Description" width="180" height="134" />

All Members list (Community -> Members list)
1. There's no no canonical url

2. og:url:

vbseo: <meta property="og:url" content="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/members/list/" />
dbseo: <meta property="og:url" content="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum" />

3. link in pagination form submit:

dbseo: <form action="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/memberlist.php?" method="get" class="pagination popupmenu nohovermenu">
vbseo: <form action="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/members/list/" method="get" class="pagination popupmenu nohovermenu">

BLOGS:
1. rss icon url:

vbseo:
<a id="rssicon" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blog_external.php?type=RSS2" rel="nofollow">
dbseo:
<a id="rssicon" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/feed/" rel="nofollow">

2. image thumbnail:

vbseo:
<img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=571529&d=1373571606&thumb=1" border="0" alt="Click image for larger version. 

Name:	923155_592598830759474_571814375_n.jpg 
Views:	1 
Size:	22.6 KB 
ID:	571529" class="thumbnail" style="float:CONFIG"/></a><br/>
dbseo:
<img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=571529&d=1373571606&thumb=1" border="0" alt="-923155_592598830759474_571814375_n.jpg" class="thumbnail" style="float:CONFIG"/></a><br/>

3. pagination_bottom:
vbseo:

<div id="pagination_bottom" class="pagination_bottom">
<form action="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index21.html?page=21" method="get" class="pagination popupmenu nohovermenu">
<input type="hidden" name="do" value="list"/>
		<span><a href="javascript://" class="popupctrl">Page 1 of 733</a></span>
		<span class="selected"><a href="javascript://" title="Results 1 to 5 of 3,662">1</a></span><span><a rel="nofollow" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index2.html?page=2" title="Show results 6 to 10 of 3,662">2</a></span><span><a rel="nofollow" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index6.html?page=6" title="Show results 26 to 30 of 3,662"><!--+5-->6</a></span><span><a rel="nofollow" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index11.html?page=11" title="Show results 51 to 55 of 3,662"><!--+10-->11</a></span><span><a rel="nofollow" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index21.html?page=21" title="Show results 101 to 105 of 3,662"><!--+20-->21</a></span>
		
		<span class="separator">...</span>
		
		
		<span class="prev_next"><a rel="next" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index2.html?page=2" title="Next Page - Results 6 to 10 of 3,662"><img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/images/pagination/next-right.png" alt="Next"/></a></span>
		
		
		<span class="first_last"><a rel="nofollow" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index733.html?page=733" title="Last Page - Results 3,661 to 3,662 of 3,662">Last<img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/images/pagination/last-right.png" alt="Last"/></a></span>
		
	
	<ul class="popupbody popuphover">
		<li class="formsubmit jumptopage"><label>Jump to page: <input type="text" name="page" size="4"/></label> <input type="submit" class="button" value="Go"/></li>
	</ul>
</form>
		</div>

dbseo:

		<div id="pagination_bottom" class="pagination_bottom">
			<form action="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blog.php?do=list&page=21" method="get" class="pagination popupmenu nohovermenu">
<input type="hidden" name="do" value="list" />
	
		<span><a href="javascript://" class="popupctrl">Page 1 of 733</a></span>
		
		
		
		<span class="selected"><a href="javascript://" title="Results 1 to 5 of 3,662">1</a></span><span><a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index2.html" title="Show results 6 to 10 of 3,662">2</a></span><span><a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index6.html" title="Show results 26 to 30 of 3,662"><!--+5-->6</a></span><span><a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index11.html" title="Show results 51 to 55 of 3,662"><!--+10-->11</a></span><span><a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index21.html" title="Show results 101 to 105 of 3,662"><!--+20-->21</a></span>
		
		<span class="separator">...</span>
		
		
		<span class="prev_next"><a rel="next" href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index2.html" title="Next Page - Results 6 to 10 of 3,662"><img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/images/pagination/next-right.png" alt="Next" /></a></span>
		
		
		<span class="first_last"><a href="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/blogs/recent-entries/index733.html" title="Last Page - Results 3,661 to 3,662 of 3,662">Last<img src="http://test.babyboom.pl/forum/images/pagination/last-right.png" alt="Last" /></a></span>
		
	
	<ul class="popupbody popuphover">
		<li class="formsubmit jumptopage"><label>Jump to page: <input type="text" name="page" size="4" /></label> <input type="submit" class="button" value="Go" /></li>
	</ul>
</form>
		</div>

 

[Fillip H.]

Just to let you know I'm not ignoring this, some of these will be addressed in Beta 6 and some I may not have time for. They'll be addressed in a future Beta if I don't have time to sort them all for this release

I should also point out that <form> tags can be safely ignored, as search engines don't crawl those URLs They're only used for submitting forms, which are usually POST requests, which search engines can't execute.