I believe I have all the settings correct for Button Click Anonymity to work, but everyone can still see who clicked the like/dislike buttons. For example, in the following post, nobody should be able to see who clicked Like, but everybody can see it - Album of the Evening - Page 430
Here are the settings for the link button. You can see I enabled Cannot See Clicks for all user groups. Thus, but clicking the link above, you as a guest shouldn't be able to see who clicked the like button.
Here are the settings for the link button. You can see I enabled Cannot See Clicks for all user groups. Thus, but clicking the link above, you as a guest shouldn't be able to see who clicked the like button.